nik1981, 09/06/2014 20:00:
Avrei preferito vedere la sorte di Tyrion
Ma soprattutto gli estranei che erano in marcia verso la barriera 3 stagioni fa, dove diavolo sono finiti?
E' un'invenzione della serie tv quella marcia oppure Martin si è dimenticato di loro?
non è un invenzione della serie TV
l'attacco dei Bruti al Castello Nero...uno dei momenti più drammatici della saga
se qualcuno si lamentava delle "poche mazzate" in questa stagione, diciamo che in questa puntata hanno recuperato tutto quello che non si è visto nelle puntate precedenti
certo è, che la situazione resta drammatica...hanno retto una notte, ma avete visto che cazzo ci sta là fuori????
attendiamo l'ultima dove (si spera) si faccia qualche chiusa sugli altri personaggi non visti in questa puntata
EDIT:
ho trovato un bel sunto che ci racconta le differenze con i libri...però mi dispiace uagliù, è in inglese
ve lo metto in spoiler qua sotto, però tranquilli che non vengono svelati fatti che avverranno in futuro:
Testo nascosto - clicca qui
In the books: The Battle of Castle Black happened almost immediately after Jon’s return to the Night’s Watch, which took place way back in episode one. This battle was slated for episode nine, however, which it why this story took a long, unsatisfying loop that involved wandering to Craster’s Keep and back again, and sending Gilly away and bringing her back.
The tactics are a bit different as well: Mance launched a diversionary attack at another tower to draw out the Night’s Watch, which he followed by a surprise attack from the South by the forces of Tormund and Ygritte. It wasn’t until after their defeat that Mance’s primary army began their attack. There is no giant Wall scythe, unfortunately, and Ghost is not at Castle Black to join the battle.
Jon never learns exactly who shot Ygritte, though he does find her wounded and she does die in his arms. Rather than Alliser Thorne, the Watch is commanded by Donal Noye, and he officially delegates the Wall to Jon when he hears that the gate is failing. It is also he who ends up dying while defending the gate against a giant named Mag the Mighty; both Grenn and Pyp survive the battle. After Noye’s death Jon takes command, with encouragement from Master Aemon, and fends off the siege for several days.
Finally, Jon doesn’t set out to find Mance after the battle, or at least not under the same terms. Instead, Alliser Thorne and Janos Slynt—who missed the battle entirely—arrive with reinforcements and arrest Jon on charges of desertion for his time with the Wildlings (which he’s already faced on the show), proving yet again that they are the Energizer bunnies of being complete asshats. Eventually, they decide to send him out to treat with Mance, thinking it a suicide mission regardless.
[Modificato da karma77 09/06/2014 21:59]